Uncommon Dissent

Tuesday, October 25, 2005

Cornell’s IDEA Club Counters Hunter Rawlings (0 comments)

On October 22, Mr. William A. Dembski pointed to a critique of ID, indulging in his traditional habit of quoting only the favorable passages. Looks like the IDEA club at Cornell read the whole thing--that's them, waving their hands, whining about ad hominem attacks, forgetting that calling someone a "non-scientist" and declaring their ideas henceforth invalid is a classic ad hominem.

Again, to quote: D'oh.

Filed under: Fun With Fallacies


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home